CertainTeed vs Owens Corning Shingles: A Comprehensive Comparison for Property Owners
When selecting the ideal roofing shingles for your property, two prominent brands often come to mind: and Owens Corning vs CertainTeed. Both manufacturers offer a range of shingle options, each with its unique advantages and considerations. This guide delves into the key differences, pros and cons, and essential factors to help you choosing between CertainTeed and Owens.
CertainTeed Shingles: Premium Quality and Durability
CertainTeed is renowned for its high-quality, heavy-duty shingles that offer exceptional durability and aesthetic appeal.
🧱 Strip Shingles (3-Tab)
The XT™ 25 is CertainTeed’s traditional 3-tab asphalt shingle, known for its affordability and simplicity. Made from a single layer of asphalt. They are ideal for homeowners on a strict budget or for replacing existing 3-tab shingles.
The XT™ 25 comes with a 25-year limited transferable warranty and a 10-year StreakFighter® warranty against algae growth.
🏗️ Architectural Shingles
Landmark® Series
The Landmark® series is CertainTeed’s multi-layered design that mimics the appearance of wood shake. Landmark shingles come with a lifetime limited transferable warranty. They also feature a 10-year StreakFighter® warranty and a 15-year 110 mph wind-resistance warranty, which can be upgraded to 130 mph.
Landmark® PRO
Building upon the standard Landmark® shingles, the Landmark® PRO offers increased durability and a richer color palette with its Max Def color options. It includes a 30-year StreakFighter® warranty.
Landmark® ClimateFlex®
Designed to withstand harsh weather conditions, the Landmark® ClimateFlex® shingles incorporate polymer-modified asphalt for enhanced impact resistance and flexibility in cold temperatures. They boast a Class 4 Impact-Resistance Rating.
Landmark® Solaris®
The Landmark® Solaris® shingles reflect more sunlight and absorb heat, helping to reduce roof temperatures and improve energy efficiency. They meet ENERGY STAR® requirements.
🏰 Luxury Shingles
Grand Manor®
The Grand Manor® shingles offer a sophisticated, slate-like appearance with deep shadow lines and a multi-layered design. They are among CertainTeed’s heaviest shingles, providing superior durability and a lifetime limited transferable warranty.
Carriage House®
Designed to replicate the look of hand-crafted slate, the Carriage House® shingles feature scalloped edges and a unique color palette. They also come with a lifetime limited transferable warranty and enhanced performance features.
Belmont®
The Belmont® shingles emulate the appearance of natural slate with a fraction of the weight and cost. They are constructed with multiple layers for added dimension and come with CertainTeed’s standard luxury shingle warranties
✅ Pros:
-
Superior Durability: CertainTeed shingles are heavier, often weighing between 250-480 lbs per square, which contributes to their enhanced durability and impact resistance.
-
Comprehensive Roofing System: The Integrity Roof System includes underlayment, starter shingles, and ridge caps designed to work seamlessly together, ensuring optimal performance.
-
Aesthetic Variety: Offers a wide range of styles and colors, including luxury options like Grand Manor and Belmont, catering to diverse architectural preferences.
-
Strong Warranty: The SureStart warranty covers 100% of shingle replacement and labor costs in the initial years post-installation.
❌ Cons:
-
Higher Cost: The premium quality comes at a higher price point compared to other brands.
-
Warranty Claims: Some homeowners have reported challenges with warranty claims, a common issue across the roofing industry.
Owens Corning Shingles: Innovative and Cost-Effective
Owens Corning is known for its innovative technologies and cost-effective shingle options that don’t compromise on quality.
🧱 3-Tab Shingles
Supreme® Shingles
The Supreme® line is Owens Corning’s traditional 3-tab shingle offering. These shingles are cost-effective and provide reliable protection against the elements. They come with a 25-year limited warranty and feature StreakGuard® Algae Resistance to prevent discoloration.
🏗️ Architectural Shingles
Oakridge® Shingles
Oakridge® shingles offer a step up from traditional 3-tab shingles, providing a more dimensional appearance and enhanced durability. They come with a limited lifetime warranty and feature StreakGuard® Algae Resistance.
TruDefinition® Duration® Series
The Duration® series is known for its advanced performance features, including SureNail® Technology for improved wind resistance up to 130 MPH. These shingles also offer vibrant TruDefinition® color options and come with a limited lifetime warranty.
TruDefinition® Duration® Designer Shingles
This line combines the performance of the Duration® series with bold, high-contrast color palettes to enhance curb appeal. They also feature SureNail® Technology and come with a limited lifetime warranty.
TruDefinition® Duration® FLEX® Shingles
Designed with SBS polymer-modified asphalt, these shingles offer enhanced flexibility and impact resistance, making them suitable for areas prone to severe weather. They come with a Class 4 Impact Resistance rating and a limited lifetime warranty.
TruDefinition® Duration® STORM® Shingles
These shingles are engineered to withstand extreme weather conditions, featuring WeatherGuard® Technology and a Class 4 Impact Resistance rating. They also include SureNail® Technology and come with a limited lifetime warranty.
TruDefinition® Duration® COOL & COOL Plus Shingles
These energy-efficient shingles reflect solar energy, helping to reduce roof temperatures. They meet ENERGY STAR® requirements and are ideal for homeowners seeking energy savings.
🏰 Luxury Shingles
Berkshire® Shingles
Berkshire® shingles offer a distinctive, slate-like appearance with large tabs and unique shadow lines. They are designed for homeowners seeking a premium look and come with a limited lifetime warranty.
Woodcrest® and Woodmoor® Shingles
These shingles emulate the natural look of wood shakes, providing a rustic aesthetic. Woodcrest® offers a more subtle texture, while Woodmoor® provides a thicker, more pronounced profile. Both lines feature StreakGuard® Algae Resistance and come with limited lifetime warranties.
✅ Pros:
-
SureNail Technology: Features a reinforced nailing zone for enhanced grip and wind resistance up to 130 mph.
-
Affordability: Offers a range of shingles suitable for various budgets, making it accessible for many homeowners.
-
Ease of Installation: Lightweight design and innovative features make installation straightforward, potentially reducing labor costs.
-
Aesthetic Options: Provides a variety of styles and colors to match different home designs.
❌ Cons:
-
Less Durable: Generally lighter and may not offer the same level of durability as CertainTeed’s heavier shingles.
-
Shorter Warranty Period: While warranties are available, they may not be as comprehensive as CertainTeed’s offerings.
Side-by-Side Comparison: CertainTeed vs. Owens Corning Shingles
| Feature | CertainTeed | Owens Corning |
|---|---|---|
| Durability | High durability with heavier shingles, such as the Landmark series, offering enhanced resistance to harsh weather conditions. | Moderate durability; lighter shingles like the Duration series provide good performance but may not match the heft of CertainTeed’s offerings. |
| Warranty | Comprehensive SureStart™ warranty with options for extended coverage, including labor and materials. | Standard limited lifetime warranty with options to upgrade to more comprehensive plans. |
| Installation | May require more labor due to the weight of the shingles, potentially increasing installation time and cost. | Easier and quicker to install owing to lighter shingle weight, which can reduce labor costs. |
| Cost | Higher price point; premium quality comes with increased material and installation costs. | More budget-friendly; offers quality roofing solutions at a lower overall cost. |
| Aesthetic Options | Wide variety, including luxury styles like the Landmark Pro and Landmark Premium series, offering diverse colors and textures. | Diverse styles and colors available, including the Duration Designer series with bold color choices. |
| Technology | Features the Integrity Roof System® and StreakFighter® algae-resistant technology for enhanced roof protection. | Incorporates SureNail® Technology for improved wind resistance and durability. |
Making the Right Choice for Your Property
When deciding between CertainTeed and Owens Corning shingles, consider the following:
-
Budget: If you’re looking for premium quality and are willing to invest more, CertainTeed may be the better choice. For cost-effective solutions, Owens Corning offers reliable options.
-
Climate: In areas prone to severe weather, CertainTeed’s heavier shingles may provide better protection.
-
Aesthetic Preferences: Both brands offer various styles, but CertainTeed has more luxury options.
-
Installation: If ease and speed of installation are priorities, Owens Corning’s lighter shingles may be advantageous.
🌟Conclusion: Which Shingles Are Better?
Both CertainTeed and Owens Corning offer high-quality roofing shingles, but the right choice depends on specific homeowner needs and preferences:
-
Choose CertainTeed if you prioritize:
-
Maximum durability and longevity.
-
Comprehensive warranty options.
-
A wide range of luxury aesthetic choices.
-
-
Choose Owens Corning if you value:
-
Budget-friendly options without compromising quality.
-
Ease and speed of installation.
-
Innovative technology for enhanced performance.
-
🌟Ultimately, both brands provide reliable roofing solutions. Consulting with a certified roofing contractor can help determine the best fit for your specific requirements and ensure a successful roof replacement.
